Physics-based Person Tracking Using the Anthropomorphic Walker
Line: 59 to 59
A possible improvement for that study would be to investigate possible controllers for generalizing over different morphologies, or even moods of characters.
The paper is well-written, but it's not very easy to follow as it incorporates ideas/methods from different areas.
Added:
> >
Contribution: The paper presents a physics-based model to track walking people in monocular video while most current methods rely on kinematic models.
Evaluation: The result is evaluated by 4 experiments. The first one tests the changes in speed from 7 to 3 km/h. The second one tests occlusion by blacking out an image region. Third one tests the track of 3D turning. The last one tests against humanEva dataset.
Reproducibility: This paper presents a complex topic. While the key ideas, formulas, and general ideas of experiments are presented with details, the actual implementation still misses a lot of explanation. It may not be easy to reproduce exactly what the paper does.
Improvement: Overall the paper is well organized and presents the key ideas very well. However I still find it is hard to follow because it requires so much background knowledge from different areas.
Baoxuan- 01 Dec 2011