Difference: TipsOnWritingACHIRebuttal (1 vs. 9)

Revision 92019-10-23 - FrancescoVitale

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 27 to 27
 

Rejected papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
CHI 2012 2.5 2 4 3 - - - - review-434.txt rebuttal-434.pdf
Added:
>
>
CHI 2019 3 2.5 3 2.5         chi-2019-rebuttal.txt CHI-2019-reviews.rtf
 

General Tips

Forming a rebuttal plan

Line: 89 to 90
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1484892231" name="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" path="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" size="4960" user="fvitale" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="chi_2018_reviews_post.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1520018903" name="chi_2018_reviews_post.txt" path="chi_2018_reviews_post.txt" size="17115" user="fvitale" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CHI_2018_rebuttal.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1520018983" name="CHI_2018_rebuttal.txt" path="CHI 2018 rebuttal.txt" size="5053" user="fvitale" version="1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CHI-2019-reviews.rtf" attr="" comment="" date="1571794804" name="CHI-2019-reviews.rtf" path="CHI-2019-reviews.rtf" size="29126" user="fvitale" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="chi-2019-rebuttal.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1571794823" name="chi-2019-rebuttal.txt" path="chi-2019-rebuttal.txt" size="5908" user="fvitale" version="1"

Revision 82018-03-02 - FrancescoVitale

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 14 to 14
 
CHI2010 4 3.5 2.5 3 4 4 3.5 4 reviews-230.rtf rebuttal-230.rtf
CHI2012 3 4.5 4.5 4         review-121.doc rebuttal-121.txt
CHI2013 2.5 4.5 4.5 3.5         review-806.txt rebuttal-806.rtf
Changed:
<
<
Conference 1AC 2AC R1 R2 R3 R6 (post-rebuttal) All post-rebuttal scores reviews rebuttal
>
>
Conference 1AC 2AC R1 R2 R3 R6 (addition post-rebuttal) All post-rebuttal scores reviews rebuttal
 
CHI2017 3.5 2.5 2.5 3.5 4.5 4 No change CHI_2017_review-1311.txt
CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt
Changed:
<
<
Conference 1AC 2AC R1 R3 1AC post-rebuttal 2AC post R1 & R3 post reviews rebuttal
CHI2018 4 4 4.5 4.5 5 (+1) 4.5 (+0.5) no change    
>
>
Conference 1AC 2AC R1 R3 1AC post-rebuttal 2AC post -rebuttal R1 & R3 post-rebuttal reviews rebuttal
CHI 2018 4 4 4.5 4.5 5 (+1) 4.5 (+0.5) no change chi_2018_reviews_post.txt CHI_2018_rebuttal.txt
 

Non-CHI papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
Line: 87 to 87
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal to HRI2013 paper" date="1384537386" name="rebuttal.1.3.docx" path="rebuttal.1.3.docx" size="18176" user="gleesonb" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CHI_2017_review-1311.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1484892076" name="CHI_2017_review-1311.txt" path="CHI_2017_review-1311.txt" size="24034" user="fvitale" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1484892231" name="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" path="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" size="4960" user="fvitale" version="1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="chi_2018_reviews_post.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1520018903" name="chi_2018_reviews_post.txt" path="chi_2018_reviews_post.txt" size="17115" user="fvitale" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CHI_2018_rebuttal.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1520018983" name="CHI_2018_rebuttal.txt" path="CHI 2018 rebuttal.txt" size="5053" user="fvitale" version="1"

Revision 72017-12-14 - FrancescoVitale

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 17 to 17
 
Conference 1AC 2AC R1 R2 R3 R6 (post-rebuttal) All post-rebuttal scores reviews rebuttal
CHI2017 3.5 2.5 2.5 3.5 4.5 4 No change CHI_2017_review-1311.txt
CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt
Added:
>
>
Conference 1AC 2AC R1 R3 1AC post-rebuttal 2AC post R1 & R3 post reviews rebuttal
CHI2018 4 4 4.5 4.5 5 (+1) 4.5 (+0.5) no change    
 

Non-CHI papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
HRI2013 4 5 2 3 - - - - review-135.docx rebuttal.1.3.docx

Revision 62017-01-20 - FrancescoVitale

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 10 to 10
 

Accepted papers

Changed:
<
<
Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal reviews rebuttal
>
>
Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal reviews rebuttal
 
CHI2010 4 3.5 2.5 3 4 4 3.5 4 reviews-230.rtf rebuttal-230.rtf
CHI2012 3 4.5 4.5 4         review-121.doc rebuttal-121.txt
CHI2013 2.5 4.5 4.5 3.5         review-806.txt rebuttal-806.rtf
Added:
>
>
Conference 1AC 2AC R1 R2 R3 R6 (post-rebuttal) All post-rebuttal scores reviews rebuttal
CHI2017 3.5 2.5 2.5 3.5 4.5 4 No change CHI_2017_review-1311.txt
CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt
 

Non-CHI papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
Line: 80 to 82
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2013 #806 submission -- accepted" date="1356313193" name="rebuttal-806.rtf" path="rebuttal-806.rtf" size="5422" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for a paper accepted to HRI2013" date="1384537307" name="review-135.docx" path="review-135.docx" size="21889" user="gleesonb" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal to HRI2013 paper" date="1384537386" name="rebuttal.1.3.docx" path="rebuttal.1.3.docx" size="18176" user="gleesonb" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CHI_2017_review-1311.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1484892076" name="CHI_2017_review-1311.txt" path="CHI_2017_review-1311.txt" size="24034" user="fvitale" version="1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attachment="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" attr="" comment="" date="1484892231" name="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" path="CHI_2017_rebuttal-1311.txt" size="4960" user="fvitale" version="1"

Revision 52016-11-18 - KaronMacLean

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 27 to 29
 
  • prioritize the concerns based on their importance
  • brief summary of how you can address each concern

Writing the rebuttal

Deleted:
<
<
  • start with thanking all the reviewers for their comments
 
Added:
>
>
Karon's version:

Keep it short, professional, succinct and very readable (e.g. use clear headings to structure), whether or not you have a tight or generous space allowance. Your English must be perfect. Remember that your meta reviewer has a huge caseload and is sick unto death of reading reviews and completely out of time.

1) Thank the reviewers for their time, and state your appreciation that the reviewers found value in X,Y,Z (this should include the things we ourselves feel are most important about this paper which the reviewers recognized).

2) List the top ~3 (or less, as needed) issues that the reviewers had important negatives or suggestions about, then address each of them in turn. Rephrase the question, explain why we did it as we did, and state how we will fix the problem in the scope of a revision, given the limits of space and time before a final submission is due.

3) In closing, you can very briefly deal with anything else - just say that the reviewers also made very helpful suggestions about x,y,z and we will be handling those within the page limits of the paper.

4) If room: thank the reviewers for any suggestions made about additional work, but do not imply that they will be addressed in this revision (in general is not a possibility).

 

Files

Revision 42013-11-15 - BrianGleeson

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 13 to 13
 
CHI2012 3 4.5 4.5 4         review-121.doc rebuttal-121.txt
CHI2013 2.5 4.5 4.5 3.5         review-806.txt rebuttal-806.rtf
Added:
>
>

Non-CHI papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
HRI2013 4 5 2 3 - - - - review-135.docx rebuttal.1.3.docx
 

Rejected papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
CHI2012 2.5 2 4 3 - - - - review-434.txt rebuttal-434.pdf
Line: 42 to 46
 
Added:
>
>

 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for a paper rejected to CHI12" date="1327952118" name="review-434.txt" path="review-434.txt" size="16535" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for 434 submission--rejected" date="1327952283" name="rebuttal-434.rtf" path="rebuttal-434.rtf" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952464" name="rebuttal-434.txt" path="rebuttal-434.txt" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
Line: 53 to 61
 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #121 submission -- accepted" date="1356311745" name="rebuttal-121.txt" path="rebuttal-121.txt" size="6133" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for an accepted CHI 2013 paper" date="1356313138" name="review-806.txt" path="review-806.txt" size="23746" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2013 #806 submission -- accepted" date="1356313193" name="rebuttal-806.rtf" path="rebuttal-806.rtf" size="5422" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for a paper accepted to HRI2013" date="1384537307" name="review-135.docx" path="review-135.docx" size="21889" user="gleesonb" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal to HRI2013 paper" date="1384537386" name="rebuttal.1.3.docx" path="rebuttal.1.3.docx" size="18176" user="gleesonb" version="1.1"

Revision 32012-12-24 - DianeTam

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 10 to 10
 
Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal reviews rebuttal
CHI2010 4 3.5 2.5 3 4 4 3.5 4 reviews-230.rtf rebuttal-230.rtf
Added:
>
>
CHI2012 3 4.5 4.5 4         review-121.doc rebuttal-121.txt
CHI2013 2.5 4.5 4.5 3.5         review-806.txt rebuttal-806.rtf
 

Rejected papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
Line: 30 to 32
 
Changed:
<
<
>
>

 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for a paper rejected to CHI12" date="1327952118" name="review-434.txt" path="review-434.txt" size="16535" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for 434 submission--rejected" date="1327952283" name="rebuttal-434.rtf" path="rebuttal-434.rtf" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952464" name="rebuttal-434.txt" path="rebuttal-434.txt" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952748" name="rebuttal-434.pdf" path="rebuttal-434.pdf" size="52876" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for an accepted CHI 2010 paper" date="1356305915" name="reviews-230.rtf" path="reviews-230.rtf" size="30349" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
Changed:
<
<
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #230 submission -- accepted" date="1356306042" name="rebuttal-230.txt" path="rebuttal-230.txt" size="5007" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #230 submission -- accepted" date="1356306422" name="rebuttal-230.rtf" path="rebuttal-230.rtf" size="5344" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2010 #230 submission -- accepted" date="1356306042" name="rebuttal-230.txt" path="rebuttal-230.txt" size="5007" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2010 #230 submission -- accepted" date="1356306422" name="rebuttal-230.rtf" path="rebuttal-230.rtf" size="5344" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for an accepted CHI 2012 paper" date="1356311677" name="review-121.doc" path="review-121.doc" size="71680" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #121 submission -- accepted" date="1356311745" name="rebuttal-121.txt" path="rebuttal-121.txt" size="6133" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for an accepted CHI 2013 paper" date="1356313138" name="review-806.txt" path="review-806.txt" size="23746" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2013 #806 submission -- accepted" date="1356313193" name="rebuttal-806.rtf" path="rebuttal-806.rtf" size="5422" user="dianetam" version="1.1"

Revision 22012-12-23 - DianeTam

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 9 to 9
 

Accepted papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal reviews rebuttal
Changed:
<
<
                     
>
>
CHI2010 4 3.5 2.5 3 4 4 3.5 4 reviews-230.rtf rebuttal-230.rtf
 

Rejected papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
Line: 28 to 28
 
Added:
>
>

 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for a paper rejected to CHI12" date="1327952118" name="review-434.txt" path="review-434.txt" size="16535" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for 434 submission--rejected" date="1327952283" name="rebuttal-434.rtf" path="rebuttal-434.rtf" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952464" name="rebuttal-434.txt" path="rebuttal-434.txt" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952748" name="rebuttal-434.pdf" path="rebuttal-434.pdf" size="52876" user="haraty" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for an accepted CHI 2010 paper" date="1356305915" name="reviews-230.rtf" path="reviews-230.rtf" size="30349" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #230 submission -- accepted" date="1356306042" name="rebuttal-230.txt" path="rebuttal-230.txt" size="5007" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #230 submission -- accepted" date="1356306422" name="rebuttal-230.rtf" path="rebuttal-230.rtf" size="5344" user="dianetam" version="1.1"

Revision 12012-01-30 - MonaHaraty

Line: 1 to 1
Added:
>
>
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Here are some useful resources on writing a CHI rebuttal.

Examples

Examples of the reviews, the reviewers' ratings (initial and post-rebuttal), and the rebuttals:

Accepted papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal reviews rebuttal
                     

Rejected papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
CHI2012 2.5 2 4 3 - - - - review-434.txt rebuttal-434.pdf

General Tips

Forming a rebuttal plan

  • start with listing all the concerns that the reviewers have raised
  • prioritize the concerns based on their importance
  • brief summary of how you can address each concern

Writing the rebuttal

  • start with thanking all the reviewers for their comments

Files

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for a paper rejected to CHI12" date="1327952118" name="review-434.txt" path="review-434.txt" size="16535" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for 434 submission--rejected" date="1327952283" name="rebuttal-434.rtf" path="rebuttal-434.rtf" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952464" name="rebuttal-434.txt" path="rebuttal-434.txt" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952748" name="rebuttal-434.pdf" path="rebuttal-434.pdf" size="52876" user="haraty" version="1.1"
 
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlCopyright © 2008-2024 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback