Difference: TipsOnWritingACHIRebuttal (1 vs. 2)

Revision 22012-12-23 - DianeTam

Line: 1 to 1
 
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Line: 9 to 9
 

Accepted papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal reviews rebuttal
Changed:
<
<
                     
>
>
CHI2010 4 3.5 2.5 3 4 4 3.5 4 reviews-230.rtf rebuttal-230.rtf
 

Rejected papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
Line: 28 to 28
 
Added:
>
>

 
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for a paper rejected to CHI12" date="1327952118" name="review-434.txt" path="review-434.txt" size="16535" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for 434 submission--rejected" date="1327952283" name="rebuttal-434.rtf" path="rebuttal-434.rtf" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952464" name="rebuttal-434.txt" path="rebuttal-434.txt" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952748" name="rebuttal-434.pdf" path="rebuttal-434.pdf" size="52876" user="haraty" version="1.1"
Added:
>
>
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for an accepted CHI 2010 paper" date="1356305915" name="reviews-230.rtf" path="reviews-230.rtf" size="30349" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #230 submission -- accepted" date="1356306042" name="rebuttal-230.txt" path="rebuttal-230.txt" size="5007" user="dianetam" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #230 submission -- accepted" date="1356306422" name="rebuttal-230.rtf" path="rebuttal-230.rtf" size="5344" user="dianetam" version="1.1"

Revision 12012-01-30 - MonaHaraty

Line: 1 to 1
Added:
>
>
META TOPICPARENT name="WebHome"

Writing a CHI rebuttal

Here are some useful resources on writing a CHI rebuttal.

Examples

Examples of the reviews, the reviewers' ratings (initial and post-rebuttal), and the rebuttals:

Accepted papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal reviews rebuttal
                     

Rejected papers

Conference R1 R2 R3 AC R1 post-rebuttal R2 post-rebuttal R3 post-rebuttal AC post-rebuttal rebuttal file comments
CHI2012 2.5 2 4 3 - - - - review-434.txt rebuttal-434.pdf

General Tips

Forming a rebuttal plan

  • start with listing all the concerns that the reviewers have raised
  • prioritize the concerns based on their importance
  • brief summary of how you can address each concern

Writing the rebuttal

  • start with thanking all the reviewers for their comments

Files

META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Review for a paper rejected to CHI12" date="1327952118" name="review-434.txt" path="review-434.txt" size="16535" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for 434 submission--rejected" date="1327952283" name="rebuttal-434.rtf" path="rebuttal-434.rtf" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952464" name="rebuttal-434.txt" path="rebuttal-434.txt" size="5245" user="haraty" version="1.1"
META FILEATTACHMENT attr="" comment="Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected" date="1327952748" name="rebuttal-434.pdf" path="rebuttal-434.pdf" size="52876" user="haraty" version="1.1"
View topic | History: r9 < r8 < r7 < r6 | More topic actions...
 
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlCopyright © 2008-2025 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback