(r3) TipsOnWritingACHIRebuttal < Imager

Tags: view all tags

%TOC%
---+Writing a CHI rebuttal
Here are some useful resources on writing a CHI rebuttal.
---++Examples
Examples of the reviews, the reviewers' ratings (initial and post-rebuttal), and the rebuttals:

---+++Accepted papers

| *Conference* | *R1* |*R2* |*R3* |*AC* |*R1 post-rebuttal* |*R2 post-rebuttal* |*R3 post-rebuttal* |*AC post-rebuttal* |reviews |rebuttal|
|CHI2010|4|3.5|2.5|3|4|4|3.5|4|[[%ATTACHURL%/reviews-230.rtf][reviews-230.rtf]]|[[%ATTACHURL%/rebuttal-230.rtf][rebuttal-230.rtf]]|
|CHI2012|3|4.5|4.5|4| | | | |[[%ATTACHURL%/review-121.doc][review-121.doc]]|[[%ATTACHURL%/rebuttal-121.txt][rebuttal-121.txt]]|
|CHI2013|2.5|4.5|4.5|3.5| | | | |[[%ATTACHURL%/review-806.txt][review-806.txt]]|[[%ATTACHURL%/rebuttal-806.rtf][rebuttal-806.rtf]]|

---+++Rejected papers
| *Conference* | *R1* |*R2* |*R3* |*AC* |*R1 post-rebuttal* |*R2 post-rebuttal* |*R3 post-rebuttal* |*AC post-rebuttal* |rebuttal file|comments|
|CHI2012|2.5|2|4|3|-|-|-|-|[[%ATTACHURL%/review-434.txt][review-434.txt]]|[[%ATTACHURL%/rebuttal-434.pdf][rebuttal-434.pdf]]|

---++General Tips
---+++Forming a rebuttal plan
   * start with listing all the concerns that the reviewers have raised
   * prioritize the concerns based on their importance
   * brief summary of how you can address each concern
---+++Writing the rebuttal
   * start with thanking all the reviewers for their comments

---++Files
   * [[%ATTACHURL%/review-434.txt][review-434.txt]]: Review for a paper rejected to CHI12

   * [[%ATTACHURL%/rebuttal-434.pdf][rebuttal-434.pdf]]: Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected

   * [[%ATTACHURL%/reviews-230.rtf][reviews-230.rtf]]: Review for an accepted CHI 2010 paper

   * [[%ATTACHURL%/rebuttal-230.rtf][rebuttal-230.rtf]]: Rebuttal for CHI 2010 #230 submission -- accepted

   * [[%ATTACHURL%/review-121.doc][review-121.doc]]: Review for an accepted CHI 2012 paper

   * [[%ATTACHURL%/rebuttal-121.txt][rebuttal-121.txt]]: Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #121 submission -- accepted

   * [[%ATTACHURL%/review-806.txt][review-806.txt]]: Review for an accepted CHI 2013 paper

   * [[%ATTACHURL%/rebuttal-806.rtf][rebuttal-806.rtf]]: Rebuttal for CHI 2013 #806 submission -- accepted

Attachments

Topic attachments
I	Attachment	History	Action	Size	Date	Who	Comment
txt	rebuttal-121.txt	r1	manage	6.0 K	2012-12-24 - 01:15	DianeTam	Rebuttal for CHI 2012 #121 submission -- accepted
rtf	rebuttal-230.rtf	r1	manage	5.2 K	2012-12-23 - 23:47	DianeTam	Rebuttal for CHI 2010 #230 submission -- accepted
txt	rebuttal-230.txt	r1	manage	4.9 K	2012-12-23 - 23:40	DianeTam	Rebuttal for CHI 2010 #230 submission -- accepted
pdf	rebuttal-434.pdf	r1	manage	51.6 K	2012-01-30 - 19:45	MonaHaraty	Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected
rtf	rebuttal-434.rtf	r1	manage	5.1 K	2012-01-30 - 19:38	MonaHaraty	Rebuttal for 434 submission--rejected
txt	rebuttal-434.txt	r1	manage	5.1 K	2012-01-30 - 19:41	MonaHaraty	Rebuttal for CHI12#434 submission--rejected
rtf	rebuttal-806.rtf	r1	manage	5.3 K	2012-12-24 - 01:39	DianeTam	Rebuttal for CHI 2013 #806 submission -- accepted
doc	review-121.doc	r1	manage	70.0 K	2012-12-24 - 01:14	DianeTam	Review for an accepted CHI 2012 paper
txt	review-434.txt	r1	manage	16.1 K	2012-01-30 - 19:35	MonaHaraty	Review for a paper rejected to CHI12
txt	review-806.txt	r1	manage	23.2 K	2012-12-24 - 01:38	DianeTam	Review for an accepted CHI 2013 paper
rtf	reviews-230.rtf	r1	manage	29.6 K	2012-12-23 - 23:38	DianeTam	Review for an accepted CHI 2010 paper

Topic revision: r3 - 2012-12-24 - DianeTam