Programming: For a programming project, you will implement a visualization system of your own. You may use existing components as the base for your system. Note that research novelty is not a requirement for a course project. There are many varieties of programming projects:
Analysis: For an analysis project, you will pick an application domain to address, and write a combination survey/analysis paper about it. No serious programming is required, so this option is suitable for non-CS students. You will include a detailed survey of previous work in the area. This survey should be more considerably detailed than the required previous work section in the programming project writeup. You will pick one or more existing software tools to to analyze a dataset from that domain, so no serious programming is required. (You may need to write some scripts to change data formats, however.) The analysis should analyze the strengths and weaknesses of those tools, and discuss in detail whether they are effective for the task that you have chosen.
Survey: For a survey paper project, you will need to read
many papers in a particular domain and write up a detailed survey.
Talk to me for more details. Again, the writeup will be much longer
than for a programming project, and this option is particularly
suitable for non-CS students.
In lecture, I will briefly discuss some of the
software packages and toolkits that you might use to build your
final project. A detailed (but not necessarily complete) list of these
packages is on the Software Resources page, and more
will be added over the course of the lectures.
You're submitting a proposal, not a specification - it's natural that
your plans will change somewhat as you refine your ideas. But your
proposal should be based on an idea that we've discussed and I've
approved. When you come talk to me about your proposal, I'll give you
some pointers to background reading in the area of your interest.
You need to meet with me the week of October 19 at the absolute
latest, and earlier would be better. While I can sign off on some
projects after only a single meeting, some people have needed two or
three meetings to find an appropriate project that gets approved.
I advise that you start by thinking about what you want your software
to do, and only then think about how you would implement it
(languages, platforms, etc). The key is to find some domain and task
that both interests you and presents an opportunity for infovis. That
is, there is some task where a human needs to understand the structure
of a large dataset. You're definitely welcome to link the infovis
project to another class or research project. You may also build on
existing software, but your project should include some implementation
work of your own.
I do not advise that you start by deciding on a language, and then
look around for some task that you might be able to do in that
language - that's backwards, and is likely to stifle your creativity.
Proposal format: your writeup should be at least two pages and
include:
One proposal per project (whether it is individual or team) is due on
October 30 by 5pm. Your proposal should be in the form of either HTML
or PDF. Send me the URL for the page to hand in the proposal. Your
email must have the following subject header:
Do not assume your classmates have read your proposal. You should
prepare a short presentation where you summarize what you're doing:
the problem and proposed solution for design study projects, the
technique ideas for technique exploration projects, the scope and
preliminary taxonomy for survey projects. Make sure you leave enough
time to explicitly discuss the progress you've made so far.
You will present the results of your project with both a presentation
and a written report. The presentation will occur during the final
exam slot for this course, and the report is also due at that time.
The reports should be at least 8-10 pages of text (programming) or
15-20 pages (analysis), and should include screen snapshots of your
running software. There is no length restriction, feel free to use as
much space as you need for images. Showing live demos of your software
in action is encouraged in the final presentation. If you are giving a
demo, be sure to practice in advance so that you don't run over your
time slot! Also remember that the audience has seen your project
update, so you don't need to repeat all of that. Focus more on your
results.
In contrast, your final report should be a standalone document that
fully describes your project. Do not assume the reader has seen your
original proposal. It should have both the structure and form of a
conference paper, using the InfoVis templates. Your
paper should include the following information:
Software
The language and platform for your project is your choice.
Proposals
You must meet with me in person to discuss your project at
least once before submitting a proposal. It may take more than one
meeting for me to sign off that you're ready to move on to the
writeup stage.
A scenario spells out what a user
would have to do and what he or she would see step-by-step in
performing a task using a given system. The key distinction
between a scenario and a task is that a scenario is
design-specific, in that it shows how a task would be
performed if you adopt a particular design, while the task
itself is design-independent: it's something the user wants to
do regardless of what design is chosen.
Subject: 533 submit proposal
Updates
The class sessions on November 16/18 will be used for project update
presentations. You should aim for 10 9
minutes each. Get your slides to me by 10am. if you're using my
laptop, and right after class if you're using your own All slides must be sent to me in advance - too much
technical chaos to try switching between laptops for 8 people in a
session. PDF preferred, PPT allowed. Exception: if you want to give a
demo on your machine, you can try, but have backup slides in your
presentation in case it doesn't work immediately. Or a backup video.
Final Presentations/Reports
Final presentation length: 10 minutes present, + 2 minutes for questions
Final report format: PDF
A few examples of particularly strong projects/papers from previous courses:
Here's the complete set of projects from previous years, to help you
judge scope and consider possibilities:
Projects From Other Courses
There are several previous infovis courses that have project
components, browsing through the final reports may help you think
about what you might like to do, and what scope is realistic for a
course project. Note that the scope of the projects may be different
at other universities, so see in particular the ones in the
previous versions of this
course for calibration.
Back to 533 Home
Tamara Munzner
Last modified: Wed Nov 4 16:13:44 PST 2009